The Woman was
Trouble
A Short Story
By
Kim L. Sellers
Los Angeles, CA
1955
It was boiling hot but ensconced in a lounge chair under an
apartment pool umbrella; I was enjoying a James Crumley novel between sips from
a tall, cold Tom Collins. The book was entertaining, but the drink was delicious.
Although not as tasty as Evie, my well-known actor neighbor looked as she basked
in the hazy yellow sunlight.
Evie was attractive, with long,
straight hair, red fire engine lips, and a sleek and black velvety body that
oozed an inky glow. But unfortunately, she had hired me to do only one thing; shoo
away her neighbors and their guests, who could be as annoying as a cadre of
paparazzi.
While sitting there, I noticed I was
rereading the same sentence. God, I hated that. I put the book down and focused
on my Tom Collins.
That was the same afternoon Dick
Francis called. He was upset.
"She's dead, Jack. Carolyn is
dead. Gerry Comer murdered her."
"What the fuck are you saying, Dick?
How did she die?"
"Gerry told the police that she
had been drinking, fell off his sailboat, and drowned. I'm sorry, Jack. I know
how much you loved her. But I'm sick to death. I didn't know what to do.
Again, I'm so sorry."
"Dick, who said Gerry murdered
her."
"No one, but I know he did."
"Don't tell anyone else. You have
no evidence or proof. You could get in trouble. I'll leave for S.F. tomorrow
morning, but keep your mouth shut. All right?"
"Okay, Jack, I understand."
"Has Gerry made any funeral
arrangements yet?
"Not yet. Jesus, Jack, I don't know."
"Well, when you do, call me,
and If I'm unavailable, leave a message with my answering service, okay?"
"Alright, Jack."
"And Dick, remember, keep your
mouth shut."
Dick Francis was Carolyn's first husband; Gerry
Comer her second. Gerry and Carolyn had been married four years. It was dumbfounding
because Carolyn had never hinted at being unhappy. If she had, I would have
been the first person she would have contacted. Meaning Carolyn and I went back
a long way.
We
first met in the fifth grade, and after we advanced, we attended the same high
school. One of the most popular girls in school, Carolyn, was also a favorite cheerleader.
But their priorities were basketball and football. Ah, football, the golden
boys.
In
my senior year, I noticed many of the school's athletes were in relationships. The
realization interested me so much that I conducted a survey under the pretense that
it was for the school newspaper and because I was the paper's sports reporter. After adding the caveat of anonymity, almost everyone agreed to share their stories.
After
several weeks and hours of interviews, the survey's results unnerved me. What I
had thought were innocent high school relationships turned out to be much more
complex.
My
survey showed a surprising number of gays, lesbians, and transsexuals. But the genuine
shock was the widespread abuse of underage sex. On a lighter note, some groups mixed fantasy sex and entertainment. For example, there were various
role play groups; doctor-nurse, firefighter-damsel in distress, and one that piqued
my interest was Roman orgies, which needed elaborate costumes. Why did it
interest me? Because Carolyn Brooks was an active member. But more about that
later.
The report
exposed darker elements, too: there was physical abuse, date rape, illegal drugs,
unwanted pregnancies, and out-of-state abortions. The practices like girlfriend
swapping and orgies, voluntary and involuntary, were copycats of the movies or
literature. Bottom-line, the high school paper's editor never would have agreed
to publish my article. But I digress.
Although
embarrassing, the dating survey's final tally was a landslide for the golden
boys. They accumulated more points than the other team sports. My wrestling
team scored a zero.
After
bugging the party organizer repeatedly, he finally relented and invited me to the
Roman fantasy. His well-off parents owned a large home on the ritzy side of
town, and their various business investments required frequent trips, which
created the perfect opportunity for the teenage fantasy party.
Dressed
as a Roman slave, it surprised me that my six-two frame and wrestling physique attracted
more than a few eyes. But Carolyn, the person I most wanted to meet, ignored me.
Too preoccupied with entertaining a crowd of teenage Roman courtiers, she didn't
notice my arrival. Carolyn's costume was a sexy, low-cut, short, white linen dress
and a sparkling rhinestone tiara that crowned her lemony blond hair. Then she
shooed the boys away after a while and approached me.
"Don't
we know each other?" She asked.
"Yes,"
I said. "We met in the fifth grade."
"I'm
sorry, but I don't remember. Where in the world have you been hiding?"
"I
don't mean to be obtuse, but in plain sight."
"Well,
shame on me."
"It's
okay. I'm a big boy."
She
felt my arm and said, "Yes, and strong, too. How can I make it up to you?"
"Would
you like to go to the bar and get a drink?"
She
slid her hand under my arm, and we walked to the crowded bar.
The
bartender asked, "What's your poison?"
Looking
at me, Carolyn said, "You look like a Jack and coke man."
"Two
Jack and cokes, with a lime twist," I said.
Carolyn
interjected, "Make it four, Ted."
"You
got it, Carolyn. Who's your friend?"
Carolyn
laughed, "I don't know. We've only met in the fifth grade."
Ted
laughed, mixed our drinks, and said, smiling, "Watch out, buddy. The girl is
trouble."
Carolyn
shot back, "Shut up, Ted."
We
took our drinks and walked back into the living room when Carolyn suggested we step
outside.
"There
are a couple of empty chairs by the pool."
On
the way outside, I suggested we forego introducing ourselves, adding, "It might
make the evening more interesting."
Carolyn
laughed, "You have quite the imagination; I like that."
"You
don't know, young lady. You do not know."
We
moved closer to the pool and put our feet in the water. Carolyn's feet were tiny,
her long legs Slim, and her short white dress had inched halfway up her thighs.
"What's
your costume supposed to be?"
"A
bathhouse gown; you know, Roman baths, sin, and corruption." She said, laughing.
"When
Caligula was emperor, women wore nothing in the bathing rooms."
"Interesting,
but I have read little about the Romans."
"Reader's
Digest published a condensed version of The Rise and Fall of the Roman
Empire. I recommend it."
"Isn't
that cutting corners?"
"Hey,
the only thing corners are good for is street signs."
"You're
funny."
"I'm
reading their version of Victor Hugo's Les Misérables.
"What's
that about?"
"Redemption."
"Do
you believe in redemption?"
"No.
I'm too young."
Carolyn
laughed, "My sentiments, exactly."
After
that night, Carolyn and I were inseparable.
One
evening, she asked, "Jack, do you want to see a movie tonight?"
"I
don't know. What's playing?"
"Is
that important?"
"No,
let's go."
After
buying popcorn and drinks, Carolyn said, "I'm going to go to the restroom."
Then, leaning closer, she whispered.
"I have a surprise. I'm not wearing panties
tonight."
After graduation,
U.C.L.A. offered scholarships to Carolyn for cheerleading and me for wrestling.
We were giddy, and we were in love. Funny how a platonic relationship can bring
two people close to insanity. We learned, however, how to pleasure each other outside
of intercourse. We were so good at it that we spent much time taking cold
baths together.
"Jack, look at my nipples. They're hard as
a rock."
"Well, they're certainly harder than me
right now."
"Don't worry, Jack, I'll take care of that
later tonight."
The
first thing Carolyn asked her U.C.L.A. Cheerleading Coach was, do the cheerleaders
support the wrestling team?
She
said, of course, but only for the home matches.
"Why,
do you ask, Carolyn?"
"My
boyfriend is on the team."
"How
long have you known him?"
"Since
the fifth grade, Coach."
"My
goodness, that's a long time."
At our college
graduation party, we tried to say our goodbyes several times, but we always cried
and felt miserable. Then, the following afternoon, while sulking in my bed, I
got sick, thinking Carolyn and I might not be in each other's lives as much as we
had been, and the thought made me so angry that I leaped out of bed, ran to the
dorm hall phone, and called her. But, of course, another student answered and
said she'd fetch her.
"Tell her it's Jack."
"Hi Jack, it's Lorraine Hoffman. Happy
Graduation."
"Thanks, Lorraine, but I need to speak to Carolyn."
"Oh, I'm sorry, I'll get her."
Answering the dorm phone was one of Carolyn's pet
peeves, and when I asked why, she said, "I'm not a goddamn maid, Jack."
When she answered, she cried, "Oh Jack, I miss
you already. Please save me."
"Okay, why don't you come over here? I have
an unopened Jack Daniels and some white stuff you like."
"What's my record?"
"Three minutes and forty-seven seconds,
door to door."
"Start the clock, Jack."
I pressed START on my wristwatch and imagined
Carolyn running through her crowded dorm hallway, down the stairs, and out the building's
front door. Of course, her first challenge would be the expansive U.C.L.A. campus. Still, Carolyn knew a shortcut, which included running through buildings, steeple jumping
over bushes, and vaulting walls until she saw the notorious and illegal outside
ladder of my dorm, the portal of everything good and evil. Then, she'd turn on
the afterburners and speed climb to the second floor, making a beeline for my
room, fighting through a gauntlet of overly friendly students.
While
I waited for her, I prepared two tall Jack and coke cocktails with a twist of lime
and ice. Next, I set up two lines of the white powder, pushed the dorm room's
windows wide open, lit a Pall Mall, took a hit, coughed, and then went to my
door, opened it just as Carolyn sprinted into the room. I pressed STOP.
"What's
my time, Jack?" Carolyn asked, trying to catch her breath while snatching the
Pall Mall and taking a drag.
"Three
minutes and forty-three seconds."
"Wahoo!
A record!"
Carolyn
began dancing around the room, cheering as she sucked her glass dry and snorted
a line of the white dirt.
"Jack,
I love you. I love you. I love you."
"Would
you like another drink?"
"Of
course. Jack, I've decided tonight is a going away party."
"It's
our graduation."
"Screw
the graduation. That's yesterday's news. Going away is happening now, and I
intend to get high as a kite."
Carolyn
paused her dancing, but her motor continued to idle as I held her fresh drink
in hand and pushed the dust-streaked mirror close enough for her to take another
hit, and after shaking her head, she grabbed her glass and began dancing again.
"Jack,
turn on the radio. I need music."
I
turned on the radio and moved the dial until I hit on "Swing Swing Swing."
"Oh,
I love Benny Goodman, Jack."
"What
do you want for dinner?"
"Chinese.
We can eat in the park."
I
poured us another drink, and Carolyn, exhausted, stopped dancing and removed her
sweaty dress. She smiled and then collapsed onto my bed. I handed her the glass.
"Thank
you, Jack. Come lay next to me. I want your arms around me."
We had dinner in bed that night and never did make it to the park.
People always said I look big for my age. I'm six-foot-two and weigh two hundred and twenty-five pounds on a good day. I was a wrestler in both high school and college and won more than my share of matches. If I had had a killer instinct. I could have won more titles. But it just wasn't in me.
I quit professional
boxing for the same reason. Opponents wanted to hurt me more than I wanted to hurt
them. My dad, who had been a successful L.A. Asst. D.A. finally suggested that I
enroll in the Los Angeles Police Academy, so I did. And after five hard years,
I passed the detective's exam, and they assigned me to the homicide division. Where
I flourished. But over time, it became clear the L.A.P.D. was so corrupt that I
resigned. So, what does an ex-cop do after
retirement? Well, I became a private investigator and my dad, fortunately, recommended
more than enough clients.
I had only
seen Carolyn off and on the last few years, and When I called to invite her to
the grand opening of my Detective Agency, she said.
"Jack,
I can't believe you're a fucking private dick?"
We
laughed.
My new offices on Wilshire
Boulevard were an ideal spot. It was on the famous Miracle Mile. It had cost me
a small fortune, but it was worth it, especially when we installed the office signage.
Merritt Detective Agency
Jack Merritt, Detective
When
Carolyn entered my office, I at once noticed she had had her hair cut in the
popular pixie style. I told her I liked it. But, for me, the change opened her
face more and stressed her eyes, which were lovely and unforgettably blue. I tried
to offer her a place to sit, but I decorated the only other chair with at least
a dozen multicolored party balloons. So, I showed her my desk chair instead.
"Cute,
Jack, but where's my party hat?"
"No
hat, but that chair has wheels."
I
shouldn't have said that because Carolyn began wheeling around the office as
though she was a drunken sailor. That's When I saw she was trying to conceal her
arm. When I looked closer, it was in a cast.
"Hey,
take it easy."
"Why?
Am I scuffing your precious floor?"
I
grabbed the chair. "How in the hell did you break your arm?"
"It
wasn't me. A creep named Tony De Franco was playing chiropractor."
"Aren't
you too old for playing doctor-nurse?"
"Tony
wasn't playing, Jack, and chiropractors aren't doctors. They're quacks."
"Forget
that. What happened?"
She
said she had met Tony De Franco at a party, that they had gotten along well and
dated. But when he began demanding benefits, they argued. Carolyn tried to
force him out of her apartment, and that's when Tony grabbed her and snapped
her arm.
"You
should have called me earlier; maybe I could've prevented this broken wing."
"Right,
easy for you to say, Jack. You'd hate me if I called you whenever I thought I
needed you."
"What
do you want me to do?"
"Talk
to him, convince him to get out of my life. Then, I don't know, twist his
goddamn fucking arm off and hand it to him."
I
laughed and couldn't stop. Then Carolyn caught the bug, and we both laughed
ourselves sick. Later, I brought out the paper cups and Jack Daniels. We got
smashed.
Two days later, I
stopped Tony in a garage, and wearing a ski mask, I beat him to an inch of his
life. Then I gritted my teeth and broke his arms. After that, Tony never
bothered Carolyn again.
Two years later, after Carolyn announced her wedding
details, I performed a quiet background check on Gerry Comer. He was clean. A successful
business executive, he paid his taxes, never had a felony arrest, and had twin
daughters from an earlier marriage, the wife deceased; the county coroner's
determination: suicide because of advanced postpartum depression syndrome.
Of course, I never
told Carolyn about the background check. She would have been aghast, except if
I had turned up something grisly, like him murdering his first wife.
Carolyn happily filled
me in on the mundane details one evening. We had bought tickets for the theater,
a real-life stage theater. We were excited.
"Gerry owns a stock
brokerage firm, a big house in Mill Valley, a condo in S.F., a Bentley,
Corvette, and a big sailboat."
"And twin
daughters," I added.
"Oh yes, Jack.
They're adorable."
"How big is
the sailboat?"
"I don't know;
I've never been on it."
"Are you going
to take a cruise around the world? As I remember, you came up short last time."
"Dammit, Jack,
now you're just being mean."
"I'm just sparring
with you, getting you ready for the main event."
"What main
event?"
"Your second marriage."
"Stop it,
Jack. I wanted to have a nice evening tonight. Not one filled with caddy
comments and sports metaphors."
"I'm sorry,
would you like another drink?"
"No, I want
the whole damn bottle."
We had an enjoyable
evening, a tasty dinner, dessert, fine wine, and after-theater drinks at a
nearby hotel, where we talked each other into spending the night.
My thoughts rolled around in my head randomly until they settled
on Dick Francis, Carolyn's first husband. I liked him. He, too, was rich.
Carolyn, several
years earlier, had blurted out her updated status while we sat at our favorite
bar.
"Jack, I'm engaged."
I stared at her for
the longest moment before saying.
"That's great,
Carolyn. So, what's the lucky man's name?"
"Dick Francis,
and he's handsome and rich, Jack, a Brentwood boy. His family owns a small,
regional airline called Western or Northwestern. I think I told you about him
hiring me last year. Two weeks ago, he proposed to me on a flight from L.A. to
San Francisco while on the family's private plane. He said he was madly in love
with me. Jack, Dick's only flaw is that he's a U.S.C. graduate. You know the
joke, university of spoiled children?"
Three
months later, at their wedding, Carolyn flashed a rock that Liz Taylor could
have killed for. They announced they were taking a cruise around the world for
their honeymoon, which sounded terrific. Aren't all honeymoons?
Then,
in the middle of their love cruise, Carolyn flew home alone. Number one on her
list was to find herself a good divorce lawyer; number two was to call me.
"I
have to see you, Jack."
"Where
are you? Where is Dick?"
"I'm
home. The last time I saw Dick, he was swimming in the Aegean."
"What
happened?"
"Irreconcilable
differences."
"What?"
"He's
a fucking mommy's boy, satisfied?"
"Well,
he's back in town."
"How
do you know?"
"He
called me."
"Are
you taking sides?"
"No,
I don't do that, but he loves you, Carolyn."
"Then
you are taking sides."
When
Carolyn sued for divorce and Dick was served, he tried suicide, except that he
dropped the gun and shot himself in the groin. It was a messy accident. They
both called me. First, Carolyn, because she wanted me to help enforce the
restraining order forbidding Dick from seeing or contacting her. Dick called
because he wanted to see his wife again before she became his ex-wife. The poor
man was a basket case, and I felt sorry for him.
After
much thought, I told them I wasn't comfortable being involved. That I wanted
out. We agreed to disagree. A week later, I received a note from Carolyn saying,
"My
Dearest Jack, I love you. I will always love you. I'm sorry that I have once
again made a mess of things. C."
The drive
from L.A. to San Francisco is long and tedious, and as I approached Bakersfield,
I saw a billboard advertising endless coffee with breakfast. So, I stopped,
thinking I would drown my sorrow in an ocean of java. Instead, the diner's
décor was orange and white: orange and white Naugahyde upholstery, orange and
white speckled countertops, and orange and white server uniforms. Even the
painted walls were orange and white. Hello, and welcome to Pumpkin Land,
weary travelers.
"Hi,
honey. How can I help you?" asked the counter server.
"A
cup of coffee, please."
As
she poured the hot, dark liquid into an orange ceramic cup, we discussed life's
more important questions.
"Do
you want to order, big boy?"
"I'll
have the steak platter."
"You're
hungry."
"Starved;
skipped breakfast."
"Your
eggs?"
"Not
runny and preferably not orange."
She
rolled her eyes. "Trust me, I get it. Hash browns or skillet potatoes with
onions?"
"Skillet."
"Anything
else, love?"
"A
newspaper?"
"Be
right back."
When
she returned with the paper, she opened it for me. I thanked her. After a few
more minutes, she brought my meal. I devoured it. Then, folding my paper, I
left fifteen dollars under the edge of my plate. It included a generous but
well-deserved tip. Then I headed to the diner's pay phone, where I called my
answering service.
The operator said, "You
have three messages, Mr. Merritt."
With my pocket
notebook and pen in hand, I said,
"I'm
ready, shoot."
"The
first message is from a Mr. Henry Wilson."
"Save."
"The
second is from a Mr. Horace Jacoby."
"Save."
"The last
message, Mr. Merritt, is from a Carolyn Comer."
"What?!
Did you say, Carolyn Comer!?"
"Yes,
sir. It's somewhat cryptic. Would you like me to read it to you?"
"Yes.
Please."
"Jack, I'm
alive. Can you believe it? Call me at this number, 6-7049. Don't worry, Jack,
I'm safe. But please call me.
I hung up the
phone and called the number. Carolyn answered. She said a trawler boat captain
had saved her life and that she was recuperating at his and his wife's home. When
I asked for more details, she said.
"Not now,
Jack. But trust me, it was a nightmare. Gerry tried to kill me."
My god, I thought,
Carolyn was alive. I couldn't believe it. But then, as I started my car, I surprised
even myself by making a solemn promise. First, I would tell Carolyn how much I truly
loved her. Then, after the mess was over. I would ask her to marry me. Hell, it
was the only way I knew to keep the woman out of trouble.
We had a lovely
June wedding, and Carolyn finally had her cruise around the world. But before our
honeymoon, while still standing at the altar, Carolyn asked.
"Where in
the hell have you been hiding all this time, Mr. Merritt?"
I said, "In
plain sight, Mrs. Merritt, plain sight."
We laughed and
then kissed.
Mazel tov.
The end.